First Team All-Atlantic Sun
| Pos. Name | School | CL | Hometown | Academic Major |
| SP Matt Hamann | Belmont | Jr. | Northbrook, Ill. | Finance |
| SP Brandon Love | Mercer | Jr. | Augusta, Ga. | Marketing |
| SP Kurt Schluter | Stetson | So. | Jupiter, Fla. | Finance |
| RP * Bo Reeder | ETSU | Jr. | Cookeville, Tenn. | Sports Management |
| C Nick Rickles | Stetson | Jr. | Loxahatchee, Fla. | Sports Management |
| 1B Adam Brett Walker | Jacksonville | So. | Milwaukee, Wis. | Sports Administration |
| 2B Robert Crews | Stetson | Jr. | Port Charlotte, Fla. | Accounting |
| 3B Jacob Tanis | Mercer | So. | Peachtree City, Ga. | Business Management |
| SS Mark Jones | Stetson | Jr. | Brunnell, Fla. | Elementary Education |
| OF Dylan Craig | Belmont | Jr. | Signal Mountain, Tenn. | Pharmaceutical Studies |
| OF Aaron Dobbs | Kennesaw State | Jr. | Warner Robins, Ga. | Communications |
| OF Blake Green | USC Upstate | Sr. | Rock Hill, S.C. | Interdisciplinary Studies |
| OF * Dan Gulbransen | Jacksonville | So. | Appleton, Wis. | Exercise Science |
| DH Nate Woods | Belmont | Sr. | Cedar Rapids, Iowa | Information Systems Management |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. Name | School | CL | Hometown | Academic Major |
| SP Chase Brookshire | Belmont | So. | Chattanooga, Tenn. | Business Administration |
| SP Derek Bushey | ETSU | So. | Richmond, Va. | Sports Management |
| SP Lindsey Caughel | Stetson | Jr. | Orlando, Fla. | Social Sciences |
| SP Steve Eagerton | Jacksonville | Jr. | Jacksonville, Fla. | Accounting |
| RP Chris Anderson | Jacksonville | Fr. | Lino Lakes, Minn. | Sports Management |
| C Ronnie Freeman | Kennesaw State | So. | Snellville, Ga. | Exercise and Health Science |
| 1B Andy Chriscaden | Kennesaw State | Jr. | Monroe, Wash. | Exercise and Health Science |
| 2B Mikel Alvarez | FGCU | Sr. | West Palm Beach, Fla. | Business |
| 3B Bo Reeder | ETSU | Jr. | Cookeville, Tenn. | Sports Management |
| SS Jimmy Howick | Jacksonville | Jr. | Jacksonville, Fla. | Sports Management |
| OF Billy Burns | Mercer | Jr. | Marietta, Ga. | Business |
| OF Thomas Carroll | Mercer | Sr. | Albany, Ga. | Business |
| OF M.L. Williams | Lipscomb | Jr. | Marietta, Ga | Accounting |
| DH Joe Winker | Mercer | Sr. | Orlando, Fla. | Business |
| Atlantic Sun All-Freshmen Team | ||||
| Pos. Name | School | Hometown | Academic Major | |
| OF * Alex Bacon | UNF | Tampa, Fla. | Engineering | |
| OF * Derrick Workman | Mercer | Acworth, Ga. | Undeclared | |
| P Chris Anderson | Jacksonville | Lino Lakes, Minn. | Sports Management | |
| P Brandon Barker | Mercer | Woodstock, Ga. | Engineering | |
| IF Greg Brody | Belmont | Dacula, Ga. | Medical Physics | |
| IF Alex Hernandez | UNF | Lake Worth, Fla. | Undeclared | |
| 2B/P D.J. Johnson | Mercer | Adel, Ga. | Business | |
| IF Shane Kennedy | UNF | Orlando, Fla. | Business | |
| P Ricky Knapp | FGCU | Port Charlotte, Fla. | Civil Engineering | |
| P Tyler Moore | UNF | Ormond Beach, Fla. | Athletic Training | |
| P Tony Mollica | Jacksonville | Jacksonville, Fla. | Business Management | |
| P Austin Perez | Stetson | Loxahatchee, Fla. | Sports Management | |
| IF Taylor Ratliff | Jacksonville | Perry, Fla. | Finance | |
| * Unanimous Selection | ||||